|
Packinghouse
Daughter: A Memoir by Cheri Register. New York: Harper Collins/Perennial,
2001 (278 pages). $13.95 paper. Originally published: St.
Paul: Minnesota Historical Society, 2000.
While
the setting of Cheri Register's memoir Packinghouse Daughter
is a Wilson meat packing plant in Albert Lea, Minnesota, her
description of a childhood time and place rings as true as
if she had grown up in my own working class family in South
Omaha in the 1950's. I remember much of the same details:
the blue work shirts that my father wore to his job at Swift's
packinghouse, the kill floor I witnessed on a school field
trip, the tense atmosphere around our house when the packinghouse
union decided to call a strike. But, more at the heart of
Packinghouse Daughter, and of my own memories, is a
fierce respect for blue collar workers, like our fathers,
who labored at their jobs to put food on the table.
In addition to drawing on her own personal memories, Register
"discovers another Albert Lea" in information gathered
from family history, personal interviews, and extensive research
in state and labor union archives. Packinghouse Daughter
is an example of the type of memoir that serves a larger purpose
than mere personal reminiscence: it not only underscores the
obvious disparity among social classes that has always existed
in America but also points to the fundamental integrity of
a typically undervalued class. Register gives the background
of her farmer grandparents, who were forced into poverty not
because of a lack of intelligence or vision but as a result
of the farm crisis of the 1920's and the Depression of the
1930's, economic events over which they had no control .
A large part of Register's book is devoted to the events surrounding
the 109-day strike at Wilson in 1959, which drew national
attention after Minnesota Governor Orville Freeman declared
martial law in Albert Lea, closing down the plant and calling
in the National Guard to quell the violence between strikers
and scabs. The emotional impact of picket signs bearing the
word "UNFAIR" on fourteen-year-old Register signals
a coming of age: "I was no longer a lovelorn teenager.
I was a proud and angry packinghouse kid living, if only momentarily,
at the center of the world." Register makes this time
in history come alive through the oftentimes poignant and
lyrical descriptions of her childhood experiences: a childhood
friendship strained by divided loyalties to either labor or
management; the kindness of union members in a neighboring
town at Christmas; her father sobbing at the kitchen table
after not being initially rehired after the strike.
The author expands on these personal experiences with an extensive
examination of union records and newspaper accounts and personal
interviews, uncovering a more complex reality than her adolescent
passion would otherwise indicate. For example, the union had
strategically timed the strike during a glut in the hog market.
Newspaper reports written during the strike characterizing
the strikers as "ruffians" revealed the pro-company
bias of the press. And, most revealing, Wilson illegally violated
the UPWA's right to strike by hiring permanent replacements,
thereafter manipulating the court system to sanction its methods.
In uncovering the story of the strike, Register raises fundamental
questions about workers' rights: Are workers, as owners would
believe, the property of the company, or, rather, do they,
by virtue of the investment of their labor, have an intrinsic
property right in the company? And doesn't a company also
have a responsibility to the community which gives it the
resources to make a profit in the first place?
While Register scrutinizes the strike from all angles, her
loyalties nonetheless are squarely with the union, which had
a solid record of protecting workers' rights in the community,
and which, as an institution, keeps "the ideal of fairness
alive" to this day. She makes no bones about picking
sides. "Ordinarily . . . I prefer to leave complexities
unresolved," she notes in her account of the illegal
tactics of Judge Cooney, the owner of Wilson during the 1959
strike, "in this case, however, one truth too easily
deteriorates into plain meanness."
Although she strongly identifies with her working-class roots,
Register, a college professor and writer, has risen to the
ranks of the middle class. Her father, as was typical of his
generation, sacrificed to make it possible for her to get
an education and avoid the grueling work of the packinghouse
(where she had no desire to work). Some readers might question
the genuineness of Register's allegiance to a life she has
voluntarily left behind. But Register admits her alienation
from her working class roots, a condition she feels makes
her even more responsible for recording her family's legacy,
an obligation, she notes, that "can weigh heavily on
those who have left our childhood environment." Register,
after all, is writing for those who were too tired at the
end of the day to write their own stories and asks of her
readers the same question that seems to have compelled her
to write Packinghouse Daughter: "What are you
doing to honor the people who raised you?"
With unions out of favor, a government that systematically
rewards the rich, and a global economy that shamelessly exploits
third-world labor, Register's story is as relevant today as
it was fifty years ago when our fathers left for work early
every morning for the packinghouse.
|